How does one respond to this or this? I am clawing for substance here but I have no concept of exactly what the critique is in either case. To many "what is wrong with X" critiques are like this.
I think criticisms should (1.) be as specific as possible, as (2.) err on the side of over-qualifying and caveating the critique, and (3.) present a version of the criticized position that others at least recognize.
Oh well - I gave it a shot.
4 hours ago