How do you define "science"?
One of the problems with the earlier exchange was that people were making claims without even establishing what "science" is. Eventually I came around to offering a rough definition. This was my critique of Razib Khan's article too - he was making critiques of social science with no clear explanation of what he was calling "science".
Anonymous comments are fine if you don't have an account and that's an obstacle to posting. No interacting or critiquing necessary. I'm just curious how readers define "science".
One Last One on Sumner vs. Murphy
4 hours ago