Saturday, September 28, 2013

Slow posting... my hands have quite literally been a little full lately

Caroline Joy Kuehn, born Thursday night after a very long but ultimately unsuccessful attempt to stay ensconced within her mommy.

Monday, September 23, 2013

John Stossel is the Daniel Tosh of the libertarian corners of the internet...

...with the principal difference being that he is not trying to be funny.

What does Sen have to do with Malthus?

A commenter questioned my association of Sen with Malthus the other day in my thinking-out-loud lecture planning, and I thought I'd elaborate a little more.

First, when I present the class with "modern Smithians" or "modern Malthusians" I like cases that don't precisely match up. Why? Because economic science is progressive and for the most part ideas persist but are changed, formalized, evolved, etc. I'm sure I could find people that think Smith or Malthus or Keynes had it EXACTLY right and that we should treat their work like scripture, but those sorts of people aren't very good representatives of economic science (and - tellingly - it's hard to find those sorts of people in the highest ranks of the science). If, instead, you have someone that takes a Smithian or Malthusian idea and then develops it, that gives the class something to talk about and think about in terms of the development of economic thought (which is, after all, what the course is about). I am very explicit about this in class discussions - that these thinkers are not exactly the same.

But there obviously has to be some continuity - so why associate Sen with Malthus? First, both were concerned with what Malthus would call "positive checks" and their impact on the poor, with population, with inequality, and with famine. So just like the endogenous fertility modelers I talked about (Oded Galor), we have a common research agenda.

But I'm not sure a common research agenda alone would be sufficient. The students actually read Malthus, they don't get the sound-bite version of Malthus, and by reading him they learn that he actually did not think that the poor were doomed to die of famine because there just wasn't enough food. Famine is one of the positive checks, but it is treated quite distinctly from the other positive checks. Malthus thinks famine is an unusual case. He notes that unlike positive checks like war or disease, people go through famine as a result of their relative ability to participate in markets. A rich person may very well die of disease (perhaps at a lower rate than the poor), but only the poor will starve to death. Famine can be ameliorated by market exchange in a way that a lot of the other positive checks can't, and therefore it is uniquely governed by the state of income distribution.

This is what we see in Sen, of course. Famines are not cases where not enough food is produced. Instead, famines are cases where not enough food can be purchased - they are a problem of distribution, not production. As a result they principally impact the lower classes.

We also talked about an interesting discussion in Malthus on why this is not widely discussed. Malthus's answer foreshadows two other modern research agendas. First, he says that nobody writes histories of the poor. People only write histories of war, politics, and the wealthy. His principle of population was likely operating for all of human history but people missed it because nobody had any interest in writing histories of the lower classes. This observation foreshadows the "social history" movement of the 1960s (which continues with force today), and of course earlier efforts at that sort of social history by Engels, etc. Malthus also argues that people have ignored the population pressures he discusses because of the difficulty of thinking in terms of real wages (remember - this is the age before price indices were easily downloadable!). He explains why nominal wages are generally downwardly rigid, and since adjustments for real wages are difficult people miss the decline in real wages. This, of course, foreshadows the burgeoning literature on real wage cyclicality in the late twentieth century.

I like this use of "modern Smithians" and "modern Malthusians" in the class. Most of the students are unfamiliar with the people I discuss, so it introduces them to important twentieth century economists. It also gives me an opportunity to make important observations on how science develops over time.

We are getting into Ricardo tomorrow (if Kate doesn't go into labor, that is). I'm probably not going to talk about any modern Ricardians on the first day (when we discuss factor prices), although I'll obviously note the proto-marginalism, or the second day on trade (except to note that this view is dominant aside from the "new trade theory", which we already discussed in the Smith class). But on the third day when we talk about Ricardo on public finance and on machinery I'm going to bring up Robert Barro as a modern Ricardian (for the public finance discussion we're going to be reading portions from his Essay on the Funding System that go over what we now call "Ricardian equivalence").

I'd be interested in hearing thoughts on any other "modern Ricardians" worth discussing in any of these classes as well.

History of Economic Ideas essay #2 options

In case anyone is interested:

*****

Assignment: Write a short essay (approximately 2,000 to 2,500 words) answering one of the following questions:
1.      When economists try to persuade other economists of the validity of their arguments they often employ “counterfactuals”. A counterfactual is a comparison case or example where all factors influencing an outcome remain the same except one factor that is of particular interest to the economist. In this sense, a counterfactual is the analog to a “control group” in an experimental setting which economists rely on because we generally don’t have access to experimental data. The differences in outcomes between the case of interest and the counterfactual can help us to infer the relationship between the factor that is not held constant between the two cases and the outcome. Thomas Malthus uses the United States as a counterfactual at two points in the readings discussed in class. Please explain in detail:

a.       Malthus’s use of the United States as a counterfactual in his essay on population. How was the United States different from Europe? How was it the same? What outcome was Malthus interested in explaining and how did he justify his arguments using the United States as a counterfactual?, and

b.      Malthus’s use of the United States as a counterfactual in his discussion of economic crises in his Principles of Political Economy. How was the United States different from Great Britain? How was it the same? What outcome was Malthus interested in explaining and how did he justify his arguments using the United States as a counterfactual?

Be sure to use quotes from Thomas Malthus in a well-written and properly cited presentation of your arguments.
 
2.      David Ricardo takes formal modeling of the economy a step farther than either Adam Smith or Thomas Malthus and lays a foundation for formal economic theory that will last at least until the 1870s. A critical component of any economic model is a theory of the determination of factor prices, and therefore the distribution of national income. Please explain in detail:

a.       Ricardo’s theory of the determinants of wage rates. How is this similar to or different from the theories of Adam Smith and Thomas Malthus on the subject?

b.      Ricardo’s theory of the determinants of profits.

c.       Ricardo’s theory on the determinants of rent. The rent of landlords is the least important factor income for modern economists. We don’t even consider it in our models! Yet Ricardo’s theory of rent is considered to be one of his most important contributions. Why?

Be sure to use quotes from David Ricardo in a well-written and properly cited presentation of your arguments. Quotes from Adam Smith and Thomas Malthus are not strictly necessary but they would certainly be appropriate to include as well.

3.      We discussed on the second day of class that Thomas Jefferson was personally acquainted with many of the Physiocrats (such as Turgot), and that he shared important social biases with Adam Smith. Jefferson also read Malthus with great interest, and maintained a correspondence with Jean Baptiste Say in France. In 1804, Jefferson wrote to Say about his thoughts on Malthus’s theory of population. Please read the letter (in the Content folder on Blackboard), and write a response to Jefferson, from the perspective of Malthus (as if Say had [with Jefferson’s permission, of course] shared the contents of the letter). Please address:

a.       A basic restatement of Malthus’s theory of population.

b.      Where you think Malthus would agree with Jefferson’s analysis and where he would disagree.

c.       A discussion of the portions of the essay on population (the sixth edition is fine to cite, even though it came out after Jefferson’s letter) that are relevant to Jefferson’s arguments.

Be sure to use quotes from Thomas Jefferson and Thomas Malthus in a well-written and properly cited presentation of your arguments.

Thursday, September 19, 2013

New Acquisition

From the library book sale, Terry Sanford's Storm over the States (1967).

Sanford was a liberal governor of North Carolina in the 1960s. In the book he talks about the problems with a federal takeover of spheres of responsibility that were previously occupied by the states. He makes the case for an active/reformist federalism.

Some of you may know that this is a personal interest of mine and the publication date of this book is of particular interest. My most important guidepost on an active, reformist federalism is my great grandfather, who had some of the same ambitions for Maryland when he presided over the (unsuccessful) state constitutional convention of 1967-68.

My (still developing) view of the problems of that time and the prospects for this sort of federalism is that hopes were dashed with the events of 1968 and with consolidation of the Great Society programs (which had already gone into effect a couple years before). States rights and federalism got a reactionary tinge and the reformists were all working at the federal level. Things could have played out differently, but they didn't.

Some things changed with the Clinton administration, but in relatively minor ways.

One day, when I'm less buried, I'd love to make more of this "stillborn reformist federalism of the 1960s" project. At this point, though, I probably won't get around to looking at this Sanford book until 201?. 15? 16? We'll see.

Fiscal multiplier project

Ryan Murphy has taken over a project on fiscal multipliers (here) which has a special emphasis on out of sample tests. He's looking for reactions to the summarization work so far, any examples of out of sample tests you're aware of, and also any other multiplier papers. I have a few thoughts on this:

Out of sample testing

First, the whole idea of an out of sample test is tough for the same reason that evaluating the Romer-Bernstein analysis was tough. When you go out of sample you are testing at least two things: (1.) the impact estimate of fiscal policy and (2.) the baseline behavior of the economy. If we are talking about multipliers just above one, often on relatively small fiscal packages it's very plausible that normal (or even abnormal) error in #2 will swamp #1. Certainly it's not easy to pull apart whether #1 or #2 are wrong.

Now let's say you can pull the two apart. Let's say, in your test out of sample, you can hold all the other things in the economy constant and look at the impact of fiscal policy in new data. What is that? Well of course it's just another multiplier estimate!

In that sense, we have lots of "out of sample tests" of multiplier estimates - it's just a new multiplier estimate. When we think about testing out of sample we're usually thinking about testing a whole system of equations that describes the economy. We don't usually think about testing a single parameter out of sample, which is sort of what this project is requesting.

These intuitions of mine seem to be confirmed by a quick scan of the articles they have that do test (or sort of test) out of sample. They're all DSGE models - namely, forecasting efforts using systems of equations that describe the whole economy. That you can test out of sample. But a single impact estimate? That's tough. Granted although I have an interest in macro I'm not a macro empirical guy, so I may be misunderstanding something.

What's interesting about multiplier studies

We've talked about a handful of multiplier studies on here before, although my knowledge of the literature is nothing near as comprehensive as what they have on this website. What I find interesting about multiplier studies - more interesting than this out-of-sample issue that they're tracking - are questions around identification strategies and what is held constant. The two points are often related. If exogenous variation across states or localities is used to identify the model, then the principle factor you're holding constant is monetary policy. That's a different sort of multiplier than the multiplier that Sumner refers to when he says that the multiplier is zero. Of course that introduces biases elsewhere associated with demand leakages across state lines. Papers that solve that problem often have the opposite problem - are they properly identifying stimulus at the national level, or is fiscal policy still endogenous? Without disparaging the work they've done, I would be interested in columns with headings like "identification strategy", "level of analysis", etc.

The other thing that is worth keeping track of with multiplier studies is the macroeconomic environment. Nobody thinks that multipliers are stable over time. Obviously structural parameters governing consumption behavior do not stay the same. But on top of that, the degree of crowding out is going to be a function of capacity utilization. It is not a coincidence that multipliers from things like war spending that are estimated in high-demand periods are lower than multipliers from narrative histories of exogenous taxes (which may come in high or low demand periods), which are themselves lower than multipliers estimated during the Great Depression. The good papers know this and interact the multiplier estimate with some variable indicative of the macroeconomic environment. That, of course, again raises the question of identification. Your fiscal variable better be well identified anyway, but it especially better be well identified if you are introducing those sorts of policy interactions.

Tuesday, September 17, 2013

Two new immigration pubs

It was very nice to see the new issue of Regulation magazine out today, because I have an article in there on high skill immigration (nothing you haven't heard from me before).

I also haven't mentioned on the blog yet that I had a featured article at EconLib this month on immigration - both high skill immigration and why people shouldn't be bothered so much by undocumented immigration.

It's a good thing Regulation came out because I found out the other article was rejected this morning (again, with great comments to move forward on). This is just how it works I guess. I've had pretty good success but that's a sign I wasn't pushing hard enough. The first rejection I knew was a reach. The second one I thought was a lot safer, but no matter. Time to clean them up and try again.

Rejection never felt so good...

...at a long-shot journal. What's funny is that I'm walking away from this feeling so good (maybe I'll feel crumbier tomorrow). The reviewers seemed to genuinely like my paper, and enthusiastically discussed things I ought to expand on. They wanted me to clean up some areas I honestly probably knew should have been cleaned up. But they liked the approach.

Revision and submission elsewhere is definitely doable.

I've got another paper out right now that I think has a much higher likelihood of being accepted - that would make me feel a lot better.

Monday, September 16, 2013

The three "modern Malthusians" I am thinking I'll talk about briefly tomorrow...

...any thoughts?

Amartya Sen - famines as a consequence of social structure rather than absolute underproduction of food (which is Malthus's view too - that was the origin of my last post. He considers the other checks so effective that he says that famines only emerge as a result of inequality and the lower classes living so close to the subsistence line and makes the point that famines rarely affect the upper classes when they do happen - so it's not that there is not enough food per se but the nature of the class structure. It's not exactly Sen's explanation but it's along the same lines).

Oded Galor - endogenous fertility models.

Casey Mulligan - incentive effects of welfare payments.

The idea, for those of you that haven't read what I'm trying to do with this class before, is to try to get them to understand connections between old and modern research agendas and the continuity and evolution of economic thought. We talk a lot about what's the same and what's different in these arguments and the older ones, particularly focusing on the impact of theoretical changes over time (for example, how does the introduction of marginalism make "modern Smithians" different from Smith himself).

They've never encountered most of these modern economists before (based on polling of the class I do when I bring them up), so it's also a nice way to familiarize them with the lay of the land.

So far we've talked very briefly about Stiglitz, Stigler, and Coase, and more extensively about Krugman, Romer, Arrow, and Vernon Smith. These three will get brief treatment (probably ten minutes in total) at the end of the class tomorrow.

I may drop Mulligan - I'm not sure. He's kind of a stand-in because everyone thinks welfare has behavioral responses. He's just a great example of that work. But I think it's nice to show the diversity of economists and perspectives that represent the Malthusian research agenda today.