Friday, May 18, 2012
Glasner on Sraffa and Hayek
Posted by
dkuehn
at
9:44 AM
I don't have time to read this now, but this old post by Glasner comes highly recommended by JP Koning. Murphy defends Sraffa in the comments. In anticipation of a fall project I've been thinking a lot the last couple weeks about whose business cycle ideas have done a better job applying Wicksell: Keynes or Hayek? When you bring Sraffa in, though, you're forced to ask yourself the question "what's the value of applying Wicksell anyway?". I do think there's value in Wicksell, but I think Sraffa's point about multiple rates of interest needs to be considered. I think you consider that point, though, by calling those multiple rates of interest "marginal efficiencies of different types of capital" and reserving the concept of "interest" for money (even then, of course, you've got lots of different time horizons and default risks to worry about). We can still talk about Hayek with all these adjustments (and I'm going to try to). I'm not one for throwing the baby out with the bathwater. But there were a lot of rough edges to work off with Hayek, and whereas Keynesians seemed to work off their rough edges over time Hayek just seemed to drop out of the conversation. I will confess, though, that I don't know Sraffa's critique nearly as well as I know Hayek or Keynes (and even with Hayek I'm not familiar with much of the PTC stuff - which is something I ought to remedy).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Daniel, I realize it is obnoxious for me to often point you to my own work when you post questions like this, but I really think I quickly get to the heart of the Sraffa/Hayek dispute (on this one point) in language that a neoclassically trained economist can understand, here.
ReplyDeleteNot obnoxious at all! Thanks.
Delete"I think you consider that point, though, by calling those multiple rates of interest "marginal efficiencies of different types of capital" and reserving the concept of "interest" for money"
ReplyDeleteHave you read chapter 17 of the General Theory? Keynes differentiates between an asset's marginal rate of capital and that same asset's own-rate (or interest rate). An own-rate is simply the spot price of some asset relative to it's own future price.
Definitely have read it... I'll need to revisit it. Thanks again for the thoughts over on Jonathan's blog.
Delete